Nov 18 2026 • min read

Getty Images v Stability AI in the Court of Appeal: can an AI model be an "infringing copy"?

The Court of Appeal has heard the appeal in Getty Images v Stability AI (CA-2026-000007). This is the first UK appeal to look at how secondary copyright infringement applies to generative AI models.  For our earlier report on the case, please see here: Pixels, precedent, and the appeal of Getty Images v. Stability AI 

Background

Getty sued Stability over its use of photographs, without consent, to train the image-generation model “Stable Diffusion”. Whilst it succeeded in part on its trade mark infringement claim, Getty abandoned its primary copyright claim at trial because the training took place outside the UK, and it lost on secondary infringement.

Secondary infringement under sections 22 and 23 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA) makes it an infringement to import, or deal in the course of business with, an "infringing copy" of a copyright work. Section 27(3) treats an imported article as an infringing copy if "its making in the UK would have constituted an infringement". This was the key battleground for the appeal.

At first instance, it was held that Stable Diffusion could be an "article", even though it is intangible. However, the judge held that an infringing copy "must be a copy" and because the model weights “never contained or stored an infringing copy", the secondary infringement claim failed. 

Getty's case: focus on the meaning of "making"

Arnold LJ quickly steered the parties to address their positive case, rather than focusing on what the judge purportedly got wrong at first instance, as the question for the Court centred around correct statutory interpretation. 

Getty argued that the meaning of “making” in the legislation was key. Counsel for Getty accepted that the model weights did not contain a copy of the copyright works, but they argued that the making of the model weights was an act of infringement because their making would have constituted an infringement of the copyright work in question if it had taken place in the UK. This was because the temporary copies of photos made in GPU memory during training were integral to, and coincided in time and place with, the making of the weights.

It also said that the judge narrowed the statutory purpose by interpreting it as protection for the owners of copyright against copying, whereas Getty argued that it should have been interpreted against the context of rewarding authors for their creative effort.

This was followed by the argument that the purpose of section 27(3) CDPA is to stop infringers getting around UK copyright law simply by moving the infringing acts abroad. Getty supported this with the 1952 Gregory Committee Report, which led to the predecessor provision in the Copyright Act 1956.

Getty said the judge overlooked Laddie J’s statement in Sony v Ball relating to the manner in which an infringing article is made, because that decision made clear that this is the moment at which it must be determined whether there is an infringing article.

Stability's case: a "copyless" infringing copy is an absurdity

Stability pointed to the consequences of Getty's reading of "making". Getty had conceded that copying an infringing copy, for example from a USB stick, would not infringe under section 17, yet it said that dealing in those fresh copies is secondary infringement. Stability said that, on Getty's case, a newly printed copy of The Hound of the Baskervilles would have been "made" in 1901, which is not a sensible reading of an Act that has been amended to deal with modern technology.

On policy, Stability argued that AI training is a societal issue for Parliament, not the courts. Because "making" also appears in section 27(2), Getty's reading would give UK rightsholders unbounded springboard-type relief and even expose defendants to criminal sanctions.

Stability also raised territoriality, saying that Getty's reading of section 27(3) would grant relief even where the training abroad was lawful or licensed.

On its Respondent's Notice, Stability argued that an "article" must be tangible. It said that "importing, possessing, exhibiting and distributing" all suit physical objects, and that Parliament used "transmit" when it meant intangibles. Section 24(2) adopts a different model for intangibles, under which the work is transmitted, copies are made on reception and liability rests with the transmitter. Stability also said that section 27 requires two filters: an article first and then an infringing copy, and that the judge wrongly allowed "infringing copy" to displace "article".

The BPI intervention

The The British Phonographic Industry (BPI) said the decision opens "a dangerous fracture" in copyright protection, particularly for the music industry. It warned that AI training could be moved offshore and the "fruits" brought back into the UK.

The BPI described section 27(3) as a "simple and hypothetical" test. If the article had been made in the UK, would its making have infringed? The BPI also asked the Court to make clear that whether AI models generally contain copies of their training data is not in issue.

Comment

How the Court of Appeal decides the appeal will help clarify one question for AI developers and creatives alike: whether the importation of model weights into the UK amounts to secondary infringement. The answer will shape the AI landscape in the UK well beyond this dispute.

If Getty succeeds, section 27(3) would become a significant tool for rightsholders. Developers could no longer rely on training models outside the UK to avoid liability when the resulting model is made available here, and the focus would shift from where the model is trained to whether training would have infringed had it taken place in the UK. That would make licensing of training data, or reliance on an applicable exception, a practical precondition for offering models in the UK market, and could encourage developers to restrict access to UK users or to seek indemnities from upstream model providers. The BPI's intervention shows that the music and wider creative industries see this as a route to protecting the value of their catalogues.

If Stability succeeds, the position at first instance would stand: a model trained abroad that does not store or reproduce the training works would fall outside UK copyright, however extensive the copying was during training. Rightsholders would then be left to pursue claims where training takes place, or to rely on claims based on model outputs and on trade marks, as Getty did with partial success at first instance.

Either way, the decision will feed directly into the Government's work on copyright and AI. Notably, the Government's report on copyright and AI said that the application of the law in this area should be considered properly by the courts, so the judgment is likely to be treated as the starting point for any reform, whether on transparency of training data, a commercial text and data mining exception or licensing. Given the importance of the issues, and the absence of any direct authority, a further appeal to the Supreme Court cannot be ruled out.

Fancy more of this sent straight into your inbox?

Sign up to our mailing list.